Hi Gill, thanks for looking. I despair of these "Nutters" there are so many of them
As you can see from the Church Records on the Home Page there are quite a few Susan Nutters, one of which was baptised 10th March 1737, father John (of Hollingreave Burnley), at St Bartholomews, Colne. The Hollingreave, Burnley could, with a bit of a stretch of the imagination, be Hollingrove, which is Briercliffe. I wouldn't have thought they would have gone to Colne from Burnley, more likely St Peters, but then again Susan and James were married at St Peters. Also their 2nd eldest son was called John, which adds a bit more credence to it. I think this is the more likely baptism, but I haven't really looked into it any more for a while-----so you have re-awakened my interest in her.
I have another Nutter ---Mary born 1792 Briercliffe, her parents were John Nutter and Susan ( possibly Kippax) -----Susan is the daughter of Robert Kippax, brother of James Kippax, Susan Nutters husband.-----Now you see why I despair of them-----